My thoughts: I read The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight a while ago, and I loved it. Not as much as The Sky is Everywhere or Anna and the French Kiss, but it was good. So when I saw this I bought it. The front cover is so awesome, and I love the title, so that was a plus.
The actual book- you know, the written words and stuff- I liked too. The prologue of emails showing how they first "met" was funny and drew you in before the story even started. I also approved of the setting- there should be more books set in small, seaside towns. The little quirky details like the framed poems and heart-shaped pancakes added a sort of rounded completeness to Ellie's life in Henley; everyone needs things like odd shaped breakfasts and their favorite poems in their world.
I thought there should have been more focus on Ellie and what she wanted, like the poetry course, or that she doesn't even like lobster (shock horror!).
The story was okay, but it was the characters and the setting that made this book good. The plot didn't really seem to go anywhere; they wasted a ton of time, then it gets all dramatic, then it just kind of trails off into uncertainty. I didn't really like the ending- for me, endings should be dramatic kisses and to-the-death duels and riding off into the sunset. This was just a whole lot of waiting around and unresolved everything. It's very uncertain, and though there's hints about whats going to happen, Smith doesn't actually say, and I find that almost as annoying as the cliff-hangers in every single Cat Clarke book I've read. It's almost like the author just got to a point where they couldn't be bothered to finish the story, so just cut it off a few pages before it was supposed to end.
So, after saying all that bad stuff about this book, I'm going to say that actually, you should read it. Despite not being as good as it could have been, I didn't feel disappointed or let down by Jennifer E Smith, and it was one of those books that kept me engrossed all the way through, because of some random book-y magic. And if that isn't enough, it does look very pretty on my shelf.